Wikipedia commentary

From Wikipedia

HomePage | Recent changes | View source | Discuss this page | Page history | Log in |

Printable version | Disclaimers | Privacy policy

Let's start moving this stuff to http://meta.wikipedia.com/ !

Some people are itching to place essay-type material on Wikipedia. Who are we to stop them? So upload your essays here. But please, follow the Wikipedia commentary area rule: Name your essay either as a subpage of the commentary page, /Like this, or as a subpage of your personal home page, Larry Sanger/Like this. Expect essays named according to any other convention to be renamed appropriately. We simply must not run the risk of people mistaking commentary for encyclopedia content.

The commentary

  • Ethics, philosophy, objectivity, religion
/Simple View of Ethics and Morals - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/A definition of Philosophy and Fields of Knowledge (Ray Van De Walker) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Drawbacks of Philosophical Understandings (Bryan Mayo) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/The Problem of Defining Sanity (Bruce Hamilton) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Investigator as Philosopher (Bruce Hamilton) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Ethics or Morals (Bruce Hamilton) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Ethics vs. Morals -- some rather old discussion about the difference between ethics and morals - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Media Bias (collectively written) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/A pome of sorts in narrative style... (Bruce Hamilton) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Folklore, myth and religion (various) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Faith vs science with regard to the Wikipedia - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Disability Etiquette - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Belief in God spectrum - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
  • The world and where it's going
/Middle East Reconciliation (Uriyan) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Stupid Republicans (author unknown) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/The best president to have a beer with (various Wikipedians) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Internet Authority Disease by Sammy snake - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
  • Content of Wikipedia
/Proposal for an Encyclopedian Recycling Endeavor (BryceHarrington) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Please help build 911 Attack memorial - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Project Sourceberg (what to do about primary sources) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
  • Form of Wikipedia
/The elements of an encyclopedia project (Larry Sanger and whoever else joins in) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Breadth and depth (Larry Sanger and others) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Modular content creation (TimShell and others) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Wiki is not paper (a discussion about ways to improve upon the traditional encyclopedia concept) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Should Wikipedia Use Profanity? (Stephen Gilbert and others) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/When should I link externally? (GWO) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Kill the Stub Pages (BryceHarrington) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Improving Portal Pages (BryceHarrington) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Get rid of subpages entirely (Larry Sanger- moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/How to write non-american names
/U.S. vs. US
/Use pinyin not Wade-Giles Moved to [the meta Wikipedia].
  • Wikipedia and where it's going
/Best debates about Wikipedia articles
/Wikipedia Anti-Rules (Anonymous and others) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/Making Wikipedia profitable (Neeklamy and others) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
/The future of Wikipedia (Kpjas and others) - moved to meta.wikipedia.com
How to Destroy Wikipedia (The Cunctator) - an open challenge
How to Build Wikipedia (The Cunctator) - an open exhortation
/Making fun of Britannica
A better Wikipedia
/The Wikipedia Community
/Search Engine
configuration management
/Responding to the Critics (Stephen Gilbert)
/Larrys Big Reply (originally on Creationism/Talk)
(AKA "The Ten Point Plan", or, "We should not impose our values on other thinking people.")
/SJKs Wikipedia-Specific License proposal
/Would Larry and Cunc just drop it please
  • Larry' section
Larry Sanger/Columns (Larry Sanger and people who respond to him)
Larrys Text -- a lot of this is in lecture format, and some of it contains my own personal opinions. I fully intend to wikify it and render it encyclopedic; I've been doing so slowly but steadily. When it's fully wiki'ed, I'll remove it from this commentary page, because it will no longer contain any commentary per se.  :-) As you can see, I am the first one to break my own rule (the item isn't filed under my name or the commentary page) but that's only because I do fully intend to make it into encyclopedia articles, and am in the process of doing so. --Larry Sanger