Tragedy of the commons

From Wikipedia

HomePage | Recent changes | View source | Discuss this page | Page history | Log in |

Printable version | Disclaimers | Privacy policy

Tragedy of the commons is a metaphor that illustrates the destruction of public resources by private interests when the best strategy for individuals conflicts with the common good. Usually, individuals seek to maximize their utility. When dealing with public goods, utility has a positive side and a negative side. The positive side is the gain that the individual gets for himself by using public property. The negative side is equal to the gain divided by the number of individuals in the community. Since the gains always overcome the losses, the best strategy for an individual is to try to exploit more than its share of public property, and since every rational individual will follow that strategy, public property gets overexploited.

The originating metaphor is of a "commons" (public pastureland) in a traditional village. Consider a pasture that can support 1250 sheep indefinitely, a population of 25 shepherds, and that each shepherd can graze and profit from 50 sheep indefinitely. By grazing one extra sheep, a shepherd can make 1/50th extra profit at a cost of only 1/1250. Thus each shepherd is tempted to "logically" keep adding sheep beyond the capacity of the commons to sustain them.

Modern equivalents are pollution of waterways, logging of forests, tossing of trash out of automobile windows. The contribution of each actor is minute, but summed over all actors, these actions degrade the resource.

The tragedy of the commons can be seen as collective prisoners dilemma. Individuals within a group have two options: cooperate with the group or defect from the group. Cooperation happens when individuals agree to protect common property to avoid the tragedy. By cooperating, every individual agrees not to seek more than their share. Defection happens when an individual realizes that it is in their interest to use more than their share of public property.

One of the leading problems of political philosophy is to articulate a solution to the tragedy of the commons. Typically, a solution involves enforcement of conservation measures by an authority, which may be an outside agency or selected by the resource users themselves, who agree to cooperate to conserve the resource.

Related pages: